Replacing a roof can start as a simple comparison of materials and estimates. For Florida homeowners planning to stay in their homes, the decision reaches well beyond installation day. A quote may leave questions about damaged decking, flashing, warranty registration, or who will handle a problem after the crew leaves. One contractor may offer a longer workmanship warranty; another may provide regular inspections and a nearby service team. Which can explain the complete reroof scope and support the system over time? The installation plan, written coverage, and ongoing care should suit the particular home.
In October 2026, we reviewed seven Florida reroof providers using their live service pages, warranty information, and public customer feedback. We assigned evidence-based editorial scores on a 0–10 scale and calculated weighted totals to compare documented offerings, rather than predict construction quality or a roof's lifespan.
The evaluation used these seven factors:
- Warranty Coverage & Accountability (25%): Published material and workmanship coverage, eligibility, transfer provisions, and help registering or using the warranty.
- Reroof Scope & Installation Documentation (20%): Evidence of roof-system assessment, installation planning, supervision, project records, and permit or inspection handling.
- Roof-System Options (15%): Verified replacement materials and system choices suited to different homes.
- Post-Installation Care (15%): Documented maintenance, inspections, repair support, and follow-up services.
- Verified Customer Evidence (10%): Review rating, sample size, relevance to reroof work, and the balance of positive and critical feedback. Different platforms and branches represent different customer populations; their star ratings are not interchangeable.
- Estimate & Cost Clarity (10%): Published estimate process, scope explanation, online quote access, financing, and disclosure of pricing limitations.
- Florida Service-Area Fit (5%): Clear regional coverage and accessible support. A regional contractor can be appropriate without serving every Florida county.
Scores reflect the relevance and specificity of the evidence: 9–10 indicates a particularly well-documented fit, 7–8.5 a useful offering with narrower scope or qualifications, and 5–6.5 more limited or mixed supporting evidence.
In the table below, the companies are ranked by their weighted totals, followed by company-by-company analysis. Each factor score appears in parentheses; totals equal the sum of those scores multiplied by their stated weights, rounded to one decimal place.
The Best Reroof Experts in Florida: Comparison Table
In the table below, we break down all seven reroof providers across all seven weighted criteria.
Scroll sideways to view the full table.
| Rank | Company | Warranty (25%) | Scope & Docs (20%) | Systems (15%) | Care (15%) | Reviews (10%) | Estimates (10%) | FL Fit (5%) | Total Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Collis Roofing | Platinum options; registration support (9.0) | Deck, flashing, ventilation; staged process (9.0) | Shingle, tile and metal (9.0) | Photo-documented maintenance; priority access (9.5) | 4.8/5; 1,582 GuildQuality reviews (9.0) | Quick Quote; personal evaluation; financing (9.0) | Four branches; county-specific coverage (9.0) | 9.1/10 |
| 2 | BFARR Contracting | Golden Pledge options; published shingle terms (9.5) | Project photo updates; inspection-led quotes (9.0) | Three shingle tiers; tile and metal (9.0) | Inspections and roof tune-up offering (8.0) | 5.0/5; 775 mixed-project reviews (9.5) | Detailed estimates; qualified financing (8.5) | Winter Park and Cocoa regional offices (8.5) | 9.0/10 |
| 3 | RIG Roofing | Transferable 10–20-year workmanship options (8.5) | Deck/underlayment checks; permit handling (9.0) | Shingle, tile, metal, TPO and PVC (9.5) | Scheduled upkeep with published inclusions (9.5) | 4.8/5 on Directorii; lower Yelp sample (7.5) | Detailed quotes; virtual-price limitations (9.0) | Central Florida focus (8.5) | 8.9/10 |
| 4 | Florida Quality Roofing | 10-year workmanship on featured tile projects (8.5) | In-house oversight; documented project examples (8.5) | Shingle, tile, metal and low-slope (9.0) | Residential repair, inspections and maintenance (8.0) | 4.5/5; 30 Yelp reviews (8.0) | Instant estimator; free consultation (8.5) | South Florida focus; other markets listed (8.0) | 8.4/10 |
| 5 | Fidus Roofing & Construction | Golden Pledge shingle-warranty options (9.0) | Daily manager; shingle/tile component assessment (9.0) | Shingle, clay/concrete tile and metal (9.0) | Published repair and maintenance services (7.5) | 3.3/5; 30 mixed-scope Yelp reviews (6.5) | Quote consultation; published system explanation (7.5) | Five Northeast Florida counties (8.0) | 8.3/10 |
| 6 | Evans Roofing | All work warrantied; system-specific terms (8.0) | Reroof assessments; documentation testimonials (7.5) | Flat, shingle, tile and metal (9.0) | Quarterly, semiannual or annual care (9.0) | 4.1/5; 44 South Florida reviews (7.0) | Free and instant quotes; financing (8.5) | Six regional service locations (9.0) | 8.2/10 |
| 7 | Covenant Roofing | Transferable company/manufacturer warranties (8.0) | No-subcontractor model; scope guidance (8.0) | Shingle, tile, metal and stone-coated options (9.5) | Repair support; transferable warranty options (7.0) | 2.8/5; 37 Leesburg Yelp reviews (5.0) | Free inspection/design; financing (8.0) | Offices across several Florida regions (9.0) | 7.8/10 |
Reroof Expert Company Profiles
Collis Roofing, for Documented Long-Term Roof Care
Collis Roofing is a family-owned Florida roofing company, specializing in residential and commercial reroofs, operating since 1994, with a branch in Longwood, serving Lakeland, Melbourne, and St. Augustine areas. It helps homeowners protect their property with honest guidance, high-quality workmanship, and roofing done right. Its replacement offering covers shingle, tile, and metal systems. The service page explains that an assessment considers the deck, underlayment, flashing, and ventilation, helping homeowners compare the complete roofing system. Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status gives qualifying installations access to enhanced warranty options, and its warranty guidance identifies labor coverage, transferable options, and registration help through the branch or estimator.
The Collis Club makes ongoing care tangible: inspections include at least 20 photographs, with maintenance covering items such as flashing sealant, exposed fasteners, debris, and gutters. Members also receive priority scheduling. BFARR's published warranty terms and customer evidence receive higher factor scores, while Collis's more detailed ongoing-care offering carries substantial weight in the combined comparison. Quick Quote provides an initial property-specific estimate, followed by the project evaluation.
- Location: Longwood, Florida; branches in Lakeland, Melbourne, and St. Augustine
- Year Founded: 1994
- Average Review Score: 4.8/5.0 (1,582 GuildQuality reviews, as of 10/2026)
- Services Offered: Shingle, tile, and metal roof replacement; repair; inspections; residential maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
Verified customers mention "answered all my questions very professionally" and "Great clean up at end of job."
BFARR Contracting, for Photo-Documented Replacement Projects
BFARR Contracting serves Central Florida homeowners who want to follow a reroof while work is underway. Customer accounts describe project photographs and written updates. Its Winter Park and Cocoa offices serve the Orlando area and Space Coast. Replacement options include shingles, tile, and metal, with three tiers of asphalt shingle systems. As a GAF Master Elite contractor, BFARR offers Golden Pledge Limited Warranty options. Its published shingle replacement information describes 50-year product coverage and a 30-year workmanship guarantee; the selected system and written warranty determine what applies.
Buyers can compare the recommended work against their budget through inspection-led estimates and financing for qualified homeowners. Its maintenance offering includes inspections, reports, and a roof tune-up program, so homeowners have a way to arrange care after installation. BFARR states that it does not repair roofs over 15 years old, a restriction to consider when planning support as the roof ages. Its maintenance page gives less detail about recurring frequency and pricing than the scheduled programs described by Collis or RIG.
- Location: Winter Park and Cocoa, Florida
- Post-Installation Care: Roof tune-ups, inspections, reports, and repairs
- Average Review Score: 5.0/5.0 (775 Trustindex-aggregated reviews, as of 10/2026; mixed project types)
- Services Offered: Shingle, tile, and metal replacement; roof repair; maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
Reroof customers describe "real-time photos" and "written updates," making progress easier to follow from a distance. The broader review feed also includes window and door installations, so its aggregate rating is not roofing-only.
RIG Roofing, for Scheduled Residential Maintenance
RIG Roofing explains both the replacement work and the steps surrounding it. Its website describes tearing off old shingles to inspect the underlayment and decking, contractor-handled permits, and estimates tailored to material and site conditions. It also explains why a virtual replacement estimate is only a ballpark figure: hidden components may add to the final scope. The company offers shingle, metal, tile, TPO, and PVC roofing. Homeowners can use those details to compare both the visible covering and work below it. Published workmanship coverage includes transferable 10- or 20-year options, with the applicable term depending on the project.
Its residential maintenance subscription sets out a follow-up schedule: the $97/year standard plan lists two annual visual inspections, while the $194/year quarterly plan lists four, as of 10/2026. Included tasks address gutters, debris, roof penetrations, flashing, nail pops, and loose shingles. The published upkeep details help explain RIG's position. Its review picture is more mixed than some competitors'. The standard maintenance pricing applies to asphalt shingle and metal roofs with pitches up to 6/12; other materials and steeper roofs require a custom quote.
- Location: Winter Haven, Florida; Central Florida service area
- Year Founded: 2005
- Average Review Score: 4.8/5.0 (619 Directorii reviews)
- Services Offered: Shingle, tile, metal, TPO, and PVC replacement; repair; residential maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
A Directorii customer reports the crew "cleaned up very thoroughly" after replacement and praises property protection. Directorii displays substantial positive feedback, although the much smaller Yelp sample has a considerably lower rating and deserves attention.
Florida Quality Roofing, for Supervised Tile Reroofs
Florida Quality Roofing has documented residential tile projects for homeowners who want to see the work and understand who oversees it. Established in 2002, the Pompano Beach company lists shingle, tile, metal, and low-slope systems in its residential offering. Its website describes hands-on project management and in-house supervision. Featured tile replacements in Fort Lauderdale and Delray Beach identify a 10-year workmanship warranty and lifetime material coverage. When comparing bids, buyers can ask which product warranty accompanies their proposed tile system and how installation coverage differs from material coverage. The featured projects provide specific examples for that discussion.
Customer accounts describe the installation work: one describes tear-off, new underlayment, and inspections, while another recounts photographs documenting rotten decking and its replacement. These are customer experiences, rather than a promise that every job follows the same sequence. The company also offers residential repairs, preventive maintenance, and free consultations, with an online estimator available for initial budgeting. Its strongest published residential focus is South Florida, although other markets are listed on the homepage.
- Location: Pompano Beach, Florida; residential focus in South Florida
- Year Founded: 2002
- Average Review Score: 4.5/5.0 (30 Yelp reviews, as of 10/2026)
- Services Offered: Shingle, tile, metal, and low-slope replacement; residential repair; inspections; preventive maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
Customers describe owner involvement, documented extra work, and clean sites. One tile-roof reviewer writes "Communication was easy and consistent," although the same review reports "manufacturing delays" outside the company's control.
Fidus Roofing & Construction, for Northeast Florida Roof-System Choices
Fidus Roofing & Construction serves St. Johns, Flagler, Duval, Clay, and Nassau counties from St. Augustine. Its residential offering includes GAF shingle systems and metal roofing, with aluminum and Galvalume options, plus clay and concrete tile replacement. Its shingle-system description identifies leak barriers and ridge-cap components; tile inspections address underlayment failure, flashing, and damaged or displaced tiles. These details help buyers compare the supporting roof components alongside the covering. Fidus says a project manager is on site daily during a reroof. Homeowners who want a nearby person responsible for the work should confirm that daily presence in the project schedule.
Its warranty explanation describes Golden Pledge options through its GAF Master Elite status, including manufacturer-backed workmanship protection on eligible systems. Homeowners should request current documents because that published comparison dates from 2021. Fidus also lists roof repair and maintenance, so homeowners can seek local support after installation. Its published service area is concentrated in five Northeast Florida counties, narrower than firms with offices across several Florida regions.
- Location: St. Augustine, Florida; St. Johns, Flagler, Duval, Clay, and Nassau counties
- Core Capabilities: Integrated GAF shingle systems; aluminum and Galvalume metal; clay and concrete tile
- Average Review Score: 3.3/5.0 (30 Yelp reviews, as of 10/2026; mixed service types)
- Services Offered: Shingle, metal, and tile installation; roof replacement; repair; maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
Published testimonials praise "high caliber people," while a Yelp highlight credits work "done correctly and in a timely way." The small, mixed-service Yelp sample has a lower overall rating, so individual roofing experiences deserve closer reading.
Evans Roofing, for Flexible Regional Maintenance
Evans Roofing has operated in Florida since 1986 and lists six regional service locations covering South Florida, Palm Beach, Central Florida, Tampa Bay, Southwest Florida, and Sarasota. Its residential services cover flat, shingle, tile, and metal roofs, including reroofs for aging or storm-damaged systems. Homeowners outside a Central Florida contractor's usual territory may find an Evans location that covers their property. Buyers can start with a free quote or an Orlando-linked instant estimator, and financing is available. Customer testimony on the residential page describes a clear explanation of included work and requested documentation.
The maintenance service offers quarterly, semiannual, or annual inspections and repairs, with custom programs designed around the customer's budget. Buyers can plan care costs alongside the replacement itself. Evans says all work is warrantied, but homeowners should obtain the material and workmanship documents for their selected system. The South Florida Best Pick Reports sample contains both favorable service feedback and a customer complaint about an undisclosed warranty-transfer fee. Buyers considering a future sale should ask about transfer costs. The report covers a regional sample, not every Evans office.
- Location: Six Florida regional service locations, including Longwood, Tampa, Boynton Beach, Cape Coral, and Bradenton
- Year Founded: 1986
- Average Review Score: 4.1/5.0 (44 Best Pick Reports reviews for South Florida, as of 10/2026)
- Services Offered: Flat, shingle, tile, and metal roofing; replacement; repair; custom maintenance
Summary of Online Reviews
Best Pick Reports customers describe service as "responsive, professional and pleasant to work with" and praise thorough estimates. Critical feedback includes a reported "fee to transfer the warranty," making written transfer terms worth checking.
Covenant Roofing, for Stone-Coated Metal Alternatives
Covenant Roofing replaces roofs with shingles, tile, metal, and stone-coated metal. Its residential page describes a stone-coated metal replacement chosen to meet a customer's HOA requirements, so buyers can discuss appearance alongside material choice. The company lists offices serving Central Florida, Northeast Florida, Bradenton, and Cocoa, and says its residential crews do not use subcontractors. Free inspections and design consultations can help homeowners compare the roof's visual finish and proposed system before deciding on a replacement.
The company publishes transferable workmanship and manufacturer warranty options for owners considering a later sale. Its homeowner guidance also encourages comparing underlayment, ventilation, flashing, cleanup, and damaged-decking provisions instead of relying on the final price alone. Repair services are available for subsequent support. Read the review evidence closely: the Leesburg Yelp sample is mixed, and a 2021 reviewer reported annual inspection fees required to preserve that customer's warranty. That historical account does not establish the terms of a current contract. Ask whether your proposed coverage requires paid inspections, who carries them out, and what happens if an inspection is missed.
- Location: Leesburg, Florida; additional regional offices serving Orlando, Northeast Florida, Bradenton, and Cocoa
- Warranty Options: Transferable workmanship and manufacturer coverage, subject to the selected contract
- Average Review Score: 2.8/5.0 (37 Yelp reviews for Leesburg, as of 10/2026)
- Services Offered: Shingle, tile, metal, stone-coated metal, and flat roofing; reroofing; repair
Summary of Online Reviews
Positive customers say Covenant "kept us informed throughout the process" and "finished the job promptly." Critical feedback includes a historical report of warranty-related inspection fees, so homeowners should review ongoing obligations before signing.
Specialty Rankings for Reroofing
We also broke down the top companies into three subcategories based on specialty.
The Top Reroof Experts for Shingle Installation Visibility
Order reflects the documented fit for a shingle reroof; ties in specialty fit are broken by Reroof Scope & Installation Documentation.
- Collis Roofing: Its staged replacement process and discussion of decking, underlayment, flashing, and ventilation help homeowners understand the full shingle-roof scope.
- RIG Roofing: Its FAQ connects shingle tear-off to inspecting the decking and underlayment and explains contractor-handled permits.
- BFARR Contracting: Reroof customers document progress photographs and written updates, giving owners visibility during installation.
- Fidus Roofing & Construction: Its integrated GAF-system explanation and stated daily project-manager presence support a supervised shingle reroof.
- Florida Quality Roofing: In-house supervision and customer accounts of photographed decking repairs provide relevant evidence of project oversight.
The Top Reroof Experts for Tile and Metal Choices
Order reflects the documented relevance of tile and metal choices; ties in specialty fit are broken by Roof-System Options.
- Covenant Roofing: Its tile, metal, and stone-coated metal offerings give homeowners an additional design route when conventional metal does not suit the home or HOA.
- RIG Roofing: Its verified range includes both tile and metal alongside other systems, helping buyers compare several replacement paths.
- Fidus Roofing & Construction: Its clay and concrete tile offering, alongside aluminum and Galvalume metal options, provides several material choices for Northeast Florida homeowners.
- Florida Quality Roofing: Named South Florida tile replacement projects and a metal-roof offering provide concrete examples to discuss during selection.
- Collis Roofing: Its replacement consultation compares tile and metal systems with warranty, maintenance, appearance, and cost considerations.
The Top Reroof Experts for Ongoing Maintenance Support
Order reflects the published maintenance scope, documentation, and roof eligibility; ties in specialty fit are broken by Post-Installation Care.
- Collis Roofing: Collis Club combines photo records, minor maintenance, and priority scheduling across several residential roof materials.
- RIG Roofing: Its two- or four-visit maintenance plans publish specific tasks and prices, with standard eligibility limited by material and roof pitch.
- Evans Roofing: Quarterly, semiannual, and annual inspection options allow homeowners to tailor a maintenance program to their budget.
- BFARR Contracting: Its published tune-up program, inspections, and reports offer a defined starting point for follow-up care.
- Florida Quality Roofing: Residential preventive maintenance, inspections, and repairs support continued care after a replacement.
Get an Instant, Property-Specific Estimate With Our Quick Quote. No In-Person Visit Required.
