Choosing a roof replacement company in Lakeland means weighing more than the lowest estimate. The right contractor should offer durable systems, clear warranty protection, proven Florida experience, and a process that helps homeowners make a confident long-term decision.
In September 2026, we evaluated eight roofing companies serving Lakeland and Polk County. Each company was scored on a 10-point scale using current company websites, published customer feedback, manufacturer credentials, service coverage, and replacement-specific information.
- Warranty Strength (20%): Manufacturer and workmanship coverage available for a full replacement.
- Lakeland/Florida Experience (20%): Documented local history and familiarity with Florida roofs, codes, heat, humidity, and storms.
- Replacement Capabilities (15%): Roof systems, materials, inspections, and installation services available to homeowners.
- Storm Expertise (15%): Florida storm experience, emergency support, and careful insurance-documentation guidance.
- Verified Reviews (15%): Current rating, review volume, and the strength of available customer evidence.
- Quote/Financing (10%): Estimate clarity, online or in-person quote options, and financing availability.
- Service Capacity (5%): Local crew depth, geographic reach, and ability to support replacement projects.
The table below compares the eight companies using those weighted factors.
Top 8 Roof Replacement Companies in Lakeland, FL: Comparison Table
In the table below, we break down all eight roof replacement companies serving Lakeland, FL across all seven criteria.
Scroll sideways to view the full table.
| Rank | Company | Warranty Strength (20%) | Lakeland/FL Experience (20%) | Replacement Capabilities (15%) | Storm Expertise (15%) | Verified Reviews (15%) | Quote/Financing (10%) | Service Capacity (5%) | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Collis Roofing | Owens Corning Platinum options and transferable coverage (9.8) | Family owned in Florida since 1994, with a Lakeland branch (9.2) | Shingle, tile, metal, inspection, and full replacement support (9.5) | Dedicated Florida hurricane experience and storm guidance (9.6) | 4.4/5 from 163 Birdeye reviews as of 09/2026 (8.2) | Instant property-specific Quick Quote and financing (9.2) | Four Florida regional hubs (9.8) | 9.3 |
| 2 | K.L. Smith Roofing | Owens Corning Platinum Preferred with transferable options (9.5) | Lakeland-based and family operated since 1973 (9.8) | Shingle, tile, metal, modified bitumen, and TPO systems (9.2) | Deep Polk County storm and code experience (8.8) | 4.95/5 from 569 Owens Corning reviews as of 07/2026 (9.4) | Free estimates and financing available (8.5) | Concentrated Polk County service area (7.5) | 9.2 |
| 3 | RIG Roofing | Up to 20-year workmanship and 30-year manufacturer coverage (9.2) | Serving Polk County since 2005 (9.0) | Shingle, metal, tile, TPO, and PVC replacements (9.4) | Emergency dry-in, tarping, and claim documentation support (8.8) | 500+ Google reviews reported; exact aggregate not stated as of 09/2026 (9.3) | Free written estimates and financing, including qualified 0% plans (9.0) | Lakeland satellite office and Winter Haven showroom (7.8) | 9.1 |
| 4 | Eustis Roofing | Manufacturer-backed options across premium roof systems (8.6) | Family-owned Central Florida company operating since 1959 (9.6) | Shingle, tile, metal, flat, and specialty replacement options (9.0) | Long Florida storm history and same-day repair support (8.6) | 4.9/5 across multiple locations as of 09/2026 (9.2) | Free estimates and no-money-down financing options (8.5) | Three listed Central Florida locations serving Lakeland (8.5) | 8.9 |
| 5 | Trimm Roofing | Atlas Diamond contractor with warranty-backed work (8.8) | 20+ years of Central Florida roofing experience (8.5) | Residential and commercial replacement across major roof types (8.8) | Dedicated storm-damage and emergency roofing services (8.7) | 4.9/5 from 135+ Google reviews as of 09/2026 (9.4) | Written line-item estimates, financing, and online estimates (8.8) | 3,000+ completed projects stated by the company (7.4) | 8.7 |
| 6 | Priority Roofing | GAF-backed products and multiple labor warranties (8.0) | National company founded in 2016; Lakeland office opened later (6.0) | Shingle, tile, metal, flat, residential, and commercial systems (8.7) | Strong storm-restoration and insurance-documentation focus (9.0) | 5.0/5 from 101 reviews displayed on the Lakeland page as of 09/2026 (7.2) | Free inspections and detailed estimates (8.4) | Multi-state network with a Lakeland branch (9.0) | 7.8 |
| 7 | Pedro's Roofing | Detailed warranty terms not publicly listed (6.8) | Lakeland-based company operating since 2017 (6.8) | Shingle, flat, TPO, repair, and replacement services (7.8) | Storm repair offered without a detailed hurricane program (7.8) | 5.0/5 from 54 Owens Corning reviews as of 07/2026 (7.5) | Free estimates and competitive-pricing focus (8.0) | Small Lakeland and Winter Haven service footprint (5.5) | 7.3 |
| 8 | Feichtel Roofing | Workmanship warranty offered; detailed terms not published (6.5) | Polk City company founded in 2023 (4.5) | Shingle, metal, tile, flat, and TPO systems (8.0) | Storm and emergency roofing services available (7.5) | Public testimonials available; no large verified aggregate found as of 09/2026 (6.5) | Free inspection and written estimate process (7.2) | Serves Polk County and broader Central Florida (5.8) | 6.5 |
Roof Replacement Companies Serving the Lakeland Area
Collis Roofing, for Warranty-Backed Statewide Capacity
Collis Roofing is a family-owned Florida roofer operating since 1994, with a Lakeland branch and four regional hubs across the state. Its residential replacement offering covers shingle, tile, and metal systems, supported by Owens Corning Platinum status, transferable warranty options, financing, and an online Quick Quote process.
This combination fits homeowners who want established Florida experience and the capacity of a larger contractor without choosing a national chain. Collis also publishes hurricane-specific guidance and emphasizes careful, local support after storms. Homeowners who prefer a small single-office contractor may find its statewide operating model less personal.
- Location: 2323 W. Memorial Blvd., Lakeland, FL 33815
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Residential roof replacement and repair; shingle, tile, and metal roofing; new construction; gutters; skylights; maintenance; commercial roofing
- Year Founded: 1994
- Average Review Score: 4.4/5.0 (163 Birdeye reviews, as of 09/2026)
Summary of Online Reviews
Customers frequently mention "quality and attention to detail" and "clear communication throughout." A smaller group reports scheduling delays during high-demand storm periods, a consideration for homeowners working against a fixed deadline.
K.L. Smith Roofing, for Long-Standing Lakeland Roots
K.L. Smith Roofing has operated in Lakeland since 1973 and remains family operated. The company offers shingle, tile, metal, modified bitumen, and TPO systems, along with Owens Corning Platinum Preferred warranty options and locally sourced shingles manufactured in Jacksonville.
Its long Polk County history and local code knowledge make it a strong fit for homeowners who value a nearby contractor with a permanent presence. Its footprint is more concentrated than companies with multiple Florida branches, which may matter for projects outside its core service area.
- Location: 2519 Buckskin Rd., Lakeland, FL 33801
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Roof replacement and repair; shingle, tile, metal, modified bitumen, and TPO roofing; inspections; storm-damage support
- Year Founded: 1973
- Average Review Score: 4.95/5.0 (569 Owens Corning reviews, as of 07/2026)
Summary of Online Reviews
Customers describe "excellent, fast and reliable service," professional communication, and confidence in completed installations. Most visible feedback is strongly positive, so homeowners may need to look beyond company-curated testimonials for a fuller complaint pattern.
RIG Roofing, for Workmanship-Warranty Options
RIG Roofing serves Lakeland from a local satellite office and a Winter Haven showroom. Its replacement offering includes shingle, metal, tile, TPO, and PVC systems, with up to a 20-year workmanship warranty, up to 30-year manufacturer coverage, free assessments, and financing.
The company is well suited to homeowners who prioritize warranty duration, material choice, and a detailed in-person assessment. RIG publishes typical Lakeland replacement ranges, but the final price still depends on roof size, materials, and decking condition.
- Location: Lakeland satellite office; Winter Haven showroom
- Price Range: Shingle replacements typically 8,000–18,000; metal and tile typically 10,000–30,000 as of 09/2026
- Services Offered: Roof replacement and repair; shingle, metal, tile, TPO, and PVC roofing; emergency dry-in and tarping; maintenance; financing
- Year Founded: 2005
- Average Review Score: Exact aggregate not stated; the Lakeland page reports 500+ Google reviews as of 09/2026
Summary of Online Reviews
Recent customers praise "communication and transparency," efficient one-day reroofs, photo documentation, and careful cleanup. At least one third-party reviewer questioned warranty follow-through, so homeowners should read the exact workmanship terms before signing.
Eustis Roofing, for Decades of Central Florida Experience
Eustis Roofing has served Central Florida since 1959 and maintains a Lakeland service-area page. It installs shingle, tile, metal, flat, and specialty roof systems and offers inspections, replacement, rejuvenation, financing, and free estimates.
Its long history and broad material selection suit homeowners who want an established regional contractor with experience across different roof types. Eustis lists offices in Orlando, Tavares, and The Villages rather than Lakeland, so homeowners should confirm crew scheduling and local follow-up expectations.
- Location: Central Florida offices serving Lakeland
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Roof replacement and repair; shingle, tile, metal, flat, specialty, and mobile-home roofing; inspections; roof cleaning; commercial roofing
- Year Founded: 1959
- Average Review Score: 4.9/5.0 across multiple locations, as of 09/2026
Summary of Online Reviews
Reviewers highlight "professional and respectful" crews, on-schedule work, clear explanations, and "impeccable" cleanup. The published 4.9 rating covers multiple locations, so it does not isolate Lakeland-specific project performance.
Trimm Roofing, for Detailed Local Estimates
Trimm Roofing brings more than 20 years of Central Florida experience and states that it has completed over 3,000 projects. The company is an Atlas Diamond contractor and offers roof replacement, repair, storm-damage service, inspections, financing, and online estimates.
It is a practical fit for homeowners who want a Lakeland-based team and a written, line-item estimate before work begins. Its Atlas credential is strong, but homeowners comparing manufacturers should confirm which enhanced warranty applies to the exact shingle system quoted.
- Location: 2500 Drane Field Rd., Suite 101, Lakeland, FL 33811
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Roof replacement and repair; shingle, tile, metal, and flat roofing; inspections; storm-damage restoration; gutters; attic ventilation
- Year Founded: Not publicly listed; company states 20+ years of experience
- Average Review Score: 4.9/5.0 (135+ Google reviews, as of 09/2026)
Summary of Online Reviews
Customers commonly mention "clear communication," clean jobsites, fast responses, and professional crews. A small number report timelines running longer than expected during busy periods, so project scheduling should be confirmed in writing.
Priority Roofing, for Insurance-Documentation Support
Priority Roofing operates a Lakeland branch within a multi-state network. Its local services include residential and commercial inspection, repair, and replacement using shingle, tile, metal, and flat systems, with GAF and industry credentials plus multiple labor-warranty options.
The company may fit homeowners whose replacement follows documented storm damage and who want help organizing photos and communicating with an insurer. Insurance coverage still depends on the policy and carrier, and the review count displayed on the Lakeland page appears to include feedback from outside markets.
- Location: 4460 Florida National Dr., Suite 4460-2, Lakeland, FL 33813
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Residential and commercial roof inspection, repair, replacement, and installation; shingle, tile, metal, and flat roofing; storm and insurance-documentation support
- Year Founded: 2016 nationally; Lakeland office established later
- Average Review Score: 5.0/5.0 (101 reviews displayed on the Lakeland page, as of 09/2026; the pool appears to include other markets)
Summary of Online Reviews
Reviewers emphasize "insurance claim guidance from start to finish" and professional crews. Because feedback displayed on the Lakeland page includes projects from other states, the rating is less useful for judging this branch alone.
Pedro's Roofing, for a Small Local Replacement Team
Pedro's Roofing is a husband-and-wife-operated Lakeland company serving Lakeland, Winter Haven, and nearby communities. It handles shingle, flat, and TPO roofs, along with replacements, repairs, installations, and storm-related work.
The smaller operating model may appeal to homeowners who prefer direct local contact and a competitive-pricing focus. The company publishes less detail about enhanced manufacturer warranties and large-project capacity than the higher-ranked contractors, so those terms should be clarified during the estimate.
- Location: Lakeland, FL 33813
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Roof replacement, repair, and installation; shingle, flat, and TPO roofing; storm repairs
- Year Founded: 2017
- Average Review Score: 5.0/5.0 (54 Owens Corning reviews, as of 07/2026)
Summary of Online Reviews
Customers describe "prompt same-day response," professional work, and an "honest company." The perfect rating comes from a smaller review sample than several competitors, so homeowners should weigh the score alongside warranty details and project scope.
Feichtel Roofing, for Broad Material Options
Feichtel Roofing is based in Polk City and serves Lakeland and Central Florida. Its residential offering includes shingle, metal, tile, flat, and TPO systems, plus inspections, repair, replacement, emergency service, estimates, and a final walkthrough with warranty coverage.
Its broad material range may suit homeowners comparing non-shingle systems. The company is newer and publishes limited warranty terms and no large verified review aggregate, giving homeowners less long-term evidence to evaluate than more established local contractors.
- Location: 416 Pine Ave., Polk City, FL 33868
- Price Range: Not publicly listed
- Services Offered: Residential roof replacement and repair; shingle, metal, tile, flat, and TPO roofing; emergency service; inspections; commercial roofing
- Year Founded: 2023
- Average Review Score: No large verified aggregate found as of 09/2026; company testimonials are available
Summary of Online Reviews
Testimonials praise "great work," a "clean job site," fast response, and reasonable pricing. The available review evidence is limited and largely published by the company, so independent local feedback stays comparatively thin.
Spin-Off Rankings
We also broke down the top companies into three subcategories based on specialty.
The Top Roof Replacement Companies in Lakeland, FL for Warranty Protection
- Collis Roofing: Owens Corning Platinum options, transferable protection, and labor-warranty support.
- K.L. Smith Roofing: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status and transferable warranty options.
- RIG Roofing: Up to 20-year workmanship and 30-year manufacturer coverage.
- Trimm Roofing: Atlas Diamond status and enhanced Atlas warranty access.
- Eustis Roofing: Manufacturer-backed options across several premium roof systems.
The Top Roof Replacement Companies in Lakeland, FL for Local Experience
- K.L. Smith Roofing: Lakeland-based since 1973.
- RIG Roofing: Serving Polk County since 2005 with a Lakeland office.
- Eustis Roofing: Central Florida operation dating to 1959.
- Collis Roofing: Florida-based since 1994 with a Lakeland branch.
- Trimm Roofing: More than 20 years of Central Florida roofing experience.
The Top Roof Replacement Companies in Lakeland, FL for Storm and Insurance Support
- Collis Roofing: Florida hurricane experience, storm guidance, and statewide crew capacity.
- Priority Roofing: Storm-restoration focus and insurance-documentation support.
- RIG Roofing: Emergency dry-in, tarping, and claim-documentation assistance.
- Trimm Roofing: Dedicated storm-damage and emergency roofing services.
- K.L. Smith Roofing: Long Polk County storm experience and insurance-claim assistance.
Have a roof concern? Call Collis Roofing at (321) 441-2300 or get a free Quick Quote
