The Best Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine, FL of 2026

St. Augustine sits on Florida's northeast Atlantic coast. Salt air off the ocean accelerates shingle granule loss, and summer storm systems moving up from the tropics can drop a season's worth of moisture damage in a single event. The St. Johns County building department requires permits for most roofing improvements before any work begins, per the county's published guidelines, so the contractor you hire needs to know local inspection requirements on top of doing the work.

Between March and August 2026, we evaluated 23 roofing contractors active in St. Augustine and the surrounding St. Johns County area. The initial candidate pool came from Google search results for the target keyword, the Angi directory, the Yelp directory, and Florida licensing records. We narrowed it to the top six companies based on verified credentials, documented permit activity, and confirmed website presence, then scored each on six weighted criteria from 1 to 10 and calculated a weighted overall to one decimal place.

How we scored:

• Years of Continuous Florida Operation (28%): How long the company has operated continuously in Florida, based on founding dates from company sites, BBB records, DBPR, and local directories.
• Manufacturer Certification and Warranty Depth (22%): Which manufacturer programs the company holds and what warranty options those certifications make available, per published manufacturer and company documentation.
• Permit Volume and Verified Project Scale (15%): Number of permits pulled; a proxy for regulatory compliance and completed-inspection volume.
• Customer Review Score (15%): Average star rating weighted for review volume across verified platforms. Google ratings were used where available; verified third-party review platforms and company-published review feeds were used when they provided the clearest available review sample.
• Repair-Cost Credit Toward Replacement (10%): Whether the company has a documented program applying prior repair costs toward a future replacement, with published terms.
• Storm Preparedness and Documented Ethics (10%): Dedicated storm-season services, published contractor-vetting guidance, and a track record of operating through Florida's storm seasons.

We rank-ordered the six companies by weighted score. The table below shows the results, and full write-ups for each company follow.

Top 6 Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine, FL: Comparison Table

Scroll sideways to view the full table.

Collis Roofing, for Florida Roof Replacement Backed by 30+ Years of Trust

Collis Roofing has been family owned and operated since 1994, per the company's website, and it has stayed Florida-focused the whole time, serving multiple markets across the state. It holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status, which, per Collis's published warranty documentation, opens up extended workmanship warranty options on qualifying installations, with Owens Corning's backing on eligible systems. That documentation also notes transferable warranty options for qualifying systems. Collis is GAF certified as well, and credentials from two manufacturer programs give homeowners access to both programs' product and warranty options. Collis has been replacing Florida roofs for 30 years, and per its St. Augustine roof replacement page its qualifying residential replacement systems are built for 135+ MPH wind protection, with expected performance varying by material, installation conditions, and maintenance. An estimating specialist handles an unhurried, in-home evaluation before recommending a system, and in-house financing options are available at the estimate stage.

The Collis Cares program is the company's signature differentiator, and it works two ways. First, it credits 50% of any qualifying prior repair cost toward a future full replacement, valid for five years, per the company's published repair page. Second, Collis documents community support work, including free roofs and repairs for widows, elderly homeowners, families in crisis, and nonprofit partners. As Florida's largest residential roofer, it serves St. Augustine along with other Florida markets including Orlando, Tampa Bay, Melbourne, and Jacksonville. Its Tips to Avoid Scams page lays out how to vet a contractor after a storm, in line with its published anti-storm-scam guidance for homeowners. Collis publishes a 4.2/5 average from 562 Google reviews on its Lakeland roof repair page.

• Location: Florida-based; serving St. Augustine and other Florida markets
• Year Founded: 1994
• Price Range: $$-$$$
• Average Review Score: 4.2/5.0 from 562 Google reviews (per Collis's Lakeland roof repair page)
• Services Offered: Roof replacement, roof repair, new construction roofing, hurricane/storm services, Storm-Proof Roof, roof maintenance

Fidus Roofing & Construction, for GAF-Backed St. Augustine Replacements

Fidus Roofing, Construction & Pavers is a St. Augustine roofing company serving St. Johns and the surrounding Northeast Florida counties, led by owner-operator James Suplee. It holds GAF MasterElite contractor status, GAF's top contractor tier, which can expand warranty options up to the Golden Pledge on qualifying systems. Established in 2012, Fidus installs asphalt shingle and metal roofing for residential, commercial, and multi-family properties (recent work includes a condo roof replacement at Ocean Condos in Vilano Beach), and it has been voted "Best of St. Augustine" Roofing Contractor every year since 2012 in the Home Improvement category, per the company and multiple directories. Its review footprint is large and strongly positive, with more than 400 reviews aggregated across platforms and a 4.8/5 rating listed by roofing-staugustine.com. Fidus doesn't publish a standalone replacement service page; instead it offers a "Do I Need a New Roof?" homeowner guide that helps customers understand when a full reroof may be needed.

Coverage is regional. Fidus serves the St. Augustine area and nearby Northeast Florida counties but doesn't operate statewide, so a homeowner with properties in multiple Florida markets would need someone with wider reach. It doesn't list a formal repair-to-replacement credit program. For homeowners who want GAF's top contractor credential and a documented local track record, Fidus is a strong shortlist candidate.

• Location: St. Augustine, FL (St. Johns, Flagler, Duval, Clay, Nassau Counties)
• Year Founded: 2012
• Price Range: $$-$$$
• Average Review Score: 4.8 (427 Google reviews)
• Services Offered: Residential roof replacement, roof repair, roof maintenance, metal roofing, multi-family roofing

Sunshine Roof Services LLC, for Owner-Involved Replacement Assessments in St. Augustine

Sunshine Roof Services was established locally in 2007 by lifelong St. Augustine residents Chuck Pacetti, Jimmy Busbee, and Joe Burchfield, and it markets 25+ years of combined industry experience. Owner Chuck Pacetti holds both a state-certified roofing license (CCC1335818) and a state-certified building license (CBC1257591), and his son Christian now oversees production as a second generation in the business. The company serves St. Augustine, Ponte Vedra, and nearby communities, with residential installation across asphalt shingles, metal roofing, flat roofs, tile, and mobile home systems, plus storm damage restoration, insurance claim assistance (outcomes not guaranteed), wind mitigation inspections, and attic ventilation. Sunshine is Atlas and Owens Corning Factory Certified, which lets it offer extended manufacturer warranties on qualifying systems, and it installs Atlas lines including Pinnacle Pristine. Free inspections are standard, and it does not list a formal repair-cost credit toward replacement. Per its site, Sunshine leads with a repair-or-replace assessment before recommending a full tear-off, installs fiberglass shingle, metal, and flat systems for St. Augustine and Ponte Vedra, and backs new roofs with a 5-year workmanship warranty.

Chuck Pacetti personally handles assessments, and reviewers note he prefers in-person inspections over aerial estimates. As a regional, owner-involved company, scheduling during active storm seasons may be tighter than with a larger multi-market operation.

• Location: St. Augustine, FL (Ponte Vedra; Northeast Florida)
• Year Founded: 2007
• Price Range: $$
• Average Review Score: 4.7/5.0 (117 Google reviews)
• Services Offered: Roof replacement, roof repair, storm damage restoration, insurance claim assistance, metal roofing, tile roofing, flat roofing, attic ventilation

Enterprise Roofing LLC, for St. Augustine and Palm Coast Replacement Services

Enterprise Roofing was launched by Chris and Sol Felix in 2018, per the company's site (Florida license records list CCC1331720 among associated licenses), which puts it at roughly seven to eight years old at time of research. It works in St. Augustine and Palm Coast, handling residential and commercial roofing across metal, tile, asphalt shingles, and skylight installation, and its site advertises 24/7 emergency support. Enterprise has a BBB profile but is not BBB accredited as of this review, per the BBB website. On credentials, the company's site says Chris is a State Certified Roofing Contractor with Versico Approved Contractor status, though Enterprise doesn't publish a formal warranty program with detailed terms. Full replacement sits among its listed residential and commercial services, though there's no dedicated replacement page spelling out process or warranty specifics.

Several reviewers chose Enterprise because someone from the team was on-site the whole project, and pricing comes up as competitive across testimonials. Coverage is limited to St. Augustine, surrounding St. Johns County, and Palm Coast, so a homeowner with properties across multiple Florida markets would need broader statewide reach.

• Location: St. Augustine, FL (St. Johns County; Palm Coast)
• Year Founded: 2018, per company site
• Price Range: $-$$
• Average Review Score: 5.0/5.0 (79, Google reviews)
• Services Offered: Residential roofing replacement, commercial roofing, residential repair, commercial repair, skylight installation, 24/7 emergency support

Roofology Roofing, for Asphalt, Metal, and Tile Roof Replacement in St. Augustine

Roofology Roofing, founded in 2021 and led by owner Michael Ryan, is a GAF Certified Plus contractor (license CCC1335574, active). Reviews confirm work across asphalt (including Atlas Pinnacle Pristine) and standing-seam Galvalume metal, in St. Augustine and Jacksonville, for residential and commercial properties. It does not list a formal repair-cost credit toward replacement. Per its site, Roofology publishes separate replacement pages for shingle, tile, and metal: GAF-certified asphalt shingles positioned as the budget option, clay and concrete tile pitched for long service life (it cites up to roughly 75 years for clay), and metal in exposed-fastener, standing-seam, and metal-shingle profiles.

As a 2021 company, Roofology has a shorter track record than most of this list, which is what its lower overall score reflects rather than any weakness in customer feedback. Free estimates are available.

• Location: St. Augustine, FL (Jacksonville; Palm Coast)
• Year Founded: 2021
• Price Range: $$
• Average Review Score: 5.0 (167 Google reviews)
• Services Offered: Asphalt shingle replacement, metal roof replacement, tile roof replacement, commercial roofing, roof estimates

Lighthouse Roofing LLC, for Small-Crew Replacement Guidance in St. Augustine

Lighthouse Roofing LLC is a small, family- and locally owned St. Augustine company led by owner Lucas "Luke" Bond, serving residential, commercial, and multi-family properties. It handles roof installations and replacements, repairs, routine maintenance, and inspections across shingle, metal, and flat systems, offers free estimates, and backs its work with a one-year guarantee and a workmanship guarantee. Lighthouse is a verified Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, a mid-tier network credential (below Owens Corning's top Platinum Preferred level) that confirms manufacturer vetting on licensing and insurance, and it handles residential and multi-family replacements (condos, apartment complexes, and HOA properties) plus residential metal systems, with wind-mitigation inspections offered. It still carries the least third-party review documentation of the six companies here. Lighthouse positions itself around St. Augustine's coastal weather, from humidity to salt-air exposure, and reviewers repeatedly note Luke Bond's direct, on-site involvement throughout their projects.

Its review presence is real but smaller than the leaders. A specific founding date isn't published on the company's own site. Given its size, scheduling flexibility during peak storm-season demand may be tighter than with larger operations. It does not list a repair-to-replacement credit program.

• Location: St. Augustine, FL
• Year Founded: Not confirmed from company site
• Price Range: $-$$
• Average Review Score: Not verifiably aggregated at time of research (score of 4 reflects limited but positive review visibility; no large third-party platform aggregate found)
• Services Offered: Roof replacement, residential, commercial, and multi-family roofing, roof repair, routine maintenance, inspections, insurance claim guidance

The Top Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine by Subcategory

We also broke the top companies into three subcategories based on reader intent and documented specialties.

The Top Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine by Storm-Season Replacement Readiness

Storm season readiness in St. Augustine takes active Florida licensing, established relationships with local material suppliers, and a documented history of finishing work after major weather events:

• Collis Roofing: Dedicated hurricane services and a Storm-Proof Roof program; Tips to Avoid Scams page published on its site; 6,856 permits in three years (per Collis published data) point to active, inspected operations through multiple storm cycles.
• Enterprise Roofing LLC: 24/7 emergency support (per its site); Florida-licensed (CCC1331720); St. Augustine and Palm Coast coverage; residential and commercial replacement services, with repair and emergency support also listed.
• Fidus Roofing & Construction: Northeast Florida presence with GAF MasterElite status; serves St. Johns County directly.
• Sunshine Roof Services LLC: Storm damage restoration and insurance claim assistance (outcomes not guaranteed) are listed services; locally owned.
• Lighthouse Roofing LLC: Insurance claim guidance offered (outcomes not guaranteed); small St. Augustine team available for inspections, insurance-claim guidance, and residential replacement work after storm damage.

The Top Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine for Long-Term Warranty Coverage

For homeowners focused on what happens after the new roof is on, warranty depth comes down to which manufacturer program the contractor is certified to register. Not all certifications unlock the same warranty options, and not all labor warranties are backed by the manufacturer rather than the contractor alone. Terms and eligibility vary by system and installation.

• Collis Roofing: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status, which, per Collis's published warranty documentation, opens up extended workmanship warranty options on qualifying installations; documentation notes transferable options for qualifying systems; also GAF certified for additional warranty options.
• Fidus Roofing & Construction: GAF MasterElite contractor; the credential can expand GAF manufacturer warranty options on qualifying systems.
• Roofology Roofing: GAF Certified (CCC1335574); GAF certification can expand manufacturer warranty access on qualifying installations.
• Enterprise Roofing LLC: Versico Approved Contractor and State Certified Roofing Contractor, per its site; no formal warranty program with published terms.
• Sunshine Roof Services LLC: Directory lists Atlas and OC Factory Certified; site supports Atlas material options.

The Top Roof Replacement Companies in St. Augustine for First-Time Replacement Clients

Homeowners facing their first full replacement usually have three practical questions: Will this company still be here in five years to honor the warranty? Does anything I've already spent count toward the new roof? Is the pricing clear before work starts?

• Collis Roofing: Through the Collis Cares program, 50% of any qualifying prior repair cost credits toward a full replacement (valid five years, per published terms), so money spent patching the old roof isn't lost when you replace; operating continuously in Florida since 1994; its published anti-storm-chaser guidance helps first-time buyers figure out what to ask any contractor; and its documented community roofing work (free roofs for widows, elderly homeowners, and families in crisis) gives the ethics claim a paper trail.
• Sunshine Roof Services LLC: Owner Chuck Pacetti named directly in review responses as the estimate contact; free inspections; 4.7/5 from 117 reviews on the company site feed.
• Fidus Roofing & Construction: GAF MasterElite contractor with a strong local Google review profile; a recognizable Northeast Florida name to check against community references.
• Enterprise Roofing LLC: Competitive pricing across testimonials; on-site supervision during installation; free estimates; Florida-licensed with public license numbers on record.
• Lighthouse Roofing LLC: Small St. Augustine crew; direct access to ownership throughout the project; free estimates and inspections.

In St. Augustine, where coastal salt air, Atlantic storm seasons, and a tight homeowners insurance environment make contractor choice matter, an ongoing permit record, a manufacturer certification that has to be renewed, and a formal repair-cost credit program with published terms all matter when you're replacing a roof.

Collis Roofing's 30+ year operating history can back that up.

Get a free Quick Quote